|
| [ IIER Home Page ] [ About IIER ]
|
Title of Manuscript: [Editor will insert title of the manuscript]
Please rate this paper on each of the following criteria by typing X into the appropriate cell.
| Poor | Fair | Good | V Gd | |
| Manuscript focuses on issues related to educational research | ||||
| Manuscript is timely | ||||
| Manuscript is significant | ||||
| Manuscript is clear, logical and concise | ||||
| Manuscript is accurate in terms of content | ||||
| Manuscript has an adequate literature review | ||||
| Manuscript reflects appropriate design and methodology | ||||
| Conclusions are based on results | ||||
| Overall rating |
[Length may vary; reviewers are encouraged to provide as much formative feedback as is reasonably possible in the context of time constraints, the honorary nature of the peer review process, and the 'double blind' convention]
Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Reject, but ask to resubmit after rewrite Reject
Last revised: 27 Apr 2009. URL: http://www.iier.org.au/about/review-form.html
HTML: Roger Atkinson [rjatkinson@bigpond.com] and Clare McBeath [c.mcbeath@bigpond.com]