Spirituality, values and the school's ethos: Factors shaping leadership in a faith-based school
Michelle Striepe, Simon Clarke and Thomas O'Donoghue
The University of Western Australia
Studies which examine how educational leadership in faith-based schools is understood and practised are few and far between in the research literature. This is surprising given the important role faith-based schools play within the Australian school system and the controversy that has often surrounded them. Taking into consideration the gap in the research and the debates surrounding these types of schools it seemed timely to examine faith-based school leaders' perspectives on educational leadership. This article describes an interpretive study which sought to uncover how members of faith-based schools' management teams understood and practised leadership. Three different faith-based schools were selected for the study; a Catholic, Islamic and Greek Orthodox school. Four different qualitative data collection methods were used, comprising semi-structured interviews, concept mapping, document analysis and non-participant observation. Using a grounded theory approach for the data analysis it was found that the ways in which these faith-based school leaders understand educational leadership are underpinned by values which often had a faith dimension. In addition, it was found that the school leaders used this framework of faith-based values to guide their practice. It is further argued that the ways in which the school leaders' values and spirituality influenced their perspectives demonstrate the influence of context on leadership perspectives.
As the field of educational leadership research has established the importance of leadership for schools (Bush & Glover, 2003), it seemed that a study investigating educational leadership within the relatively neglected context of faith-based schools would offer an intriguing setting for research (Striepe, 2011; Striepe & Clarke, 2009). This article describes a study which aimed to reveal how members of faith-based school management teams understood and practised leadership. The article identifies three key themes that evolved from the findings which illustrate how the participants' perspectives of leadership were driven by values and influenced by personal factors that often had a faith-dimension. In addition, it is argued that this study reiterates the need for educational leadership research to focus on the influence of context and for the field to conceptualise leadership from more diverse perspectives than has traditionally been the norm.
The international context of faith-based schools shares similarities with the context of faith-based schools within Australia. Australian faith-based schools are broadly referred to as non-government schools and are more specifically categorised as Catholic, or independent, schools. It is important to note that the majority of independent schools have a religious affiliation (Independent Schools Council of Australia, 2012). Faith-based schools have existed within Australia for over 150 years and since World War II this sector has significantly expanded its numbers and types of schools (Campbell, Proctor & Sherington, 2009; Symes & Gulson, 2008). As a result of the increase in faith-based schools, this sector plays an important role in Australia's education system (Striepe & Clarke, 2009). The latest national statistics reveal that 35 per cent of all full-time students are in non-government schools (ABS, 2012; ISCA, 2012). Thus, it is not surprising that in comparison to other OECD countries, Australia has a large percentage of full-time students who attend non-government schools (Crump & Slee, 2005).
Research investigating faith-based schools within Australia is beginning to expand. However, much of what has been produced concentrates on developing frameworks of educational leadership in the Catholic school sector (Spry, Duignan & Skelly, 2004; Whelan, Slattery & Cannon, 2007), or investigates issues connected with the preparation and retention of faith-based school leaders, particularly in the eastern states of Australia (Dorman & d'Arbon, 2003, d'Arbon, Duignan & Duncan, 2002). Consequently, it could be argued that research which focuses on understanding leadership from the perspectives of faith-based school leaders, particularly those in Western Australia, has not received the same amount of attention.
The distinct contexts of faith-based schools, which derive from their distinguishing purposes, characteristics and ethos that influence the school's aims and environments (Halstead & McLaughlin, 2005; McGettrick, 2005) are particularly amenable for developing insights into understandings and practices of educational leadership. In addition, the purposes and ethos of faith-based schools are affected by factors such as: the school's particular faith, its religious traditions and the processes the school uses to select students and hire staff (Halstead & McLaughlin, 2005; McGettrick, 2005). It seems self-evident, therefore, that these distinctive contexts along with the values and beliefs of the school's faith may shape the ways in which educational leadership is understood and practised (McGettrick, 2005; Sacks, 2004).
It seemed especially apposite to locate an investigation of educational leadership within the context of Western Australia's (WA) faith-based schools. The growth of the faith-based school sector within Australia's education system is mirrored in this more specific context of WA. In this context the faith-based sector has flourished. This is demonstrated by the fact that during the period from 1998-2008, nearly all of the new schools established in Western Australia were either Catholic or independent (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2009, 2012). It is important to point out that in WA the vast majority of independent schools, nearly 80 per cent, has a religious affiliation. As a result of this growth these types of schools are now responsible for educating over a third of all students in the state (ABS, 2009, 2012).
How do the members of management teams in different faith-based schools understand and practise educational leadership?
The final selection of the cases comprised three composite (K-12), faith-based schools, namely, a Catholic school, an Islamic school and a Greek Orthodox school. These three faith-based schools were selected on the basis that each of them had distinct aims and environments which were influenced by the school's affiliation with a particular faith.
The Catholic school is a part of a wider Catholic system which oversees 160 schools in Western Australia. The values and beliefs of the Catholic Church drive the aims of the school and influence other aspects of the school including its numerous community service programs. This K-12 co-educational school serves nearly 1500 students from a variety of backgrounds.
The Islamic school is a part of a small independent school system that is affiliated with the local Islamic community. The aims and culture of the school are to a large extent determined by its affiliation with the Islamic faith. The importance of upholding Islamic values is considered essential for the school's large student population, which numbered approximately 1,000 at the time of the research.
The Greek Orthodox school is a co-educational independent school which serves nearly 500 students. The nearby office of the Hellenic Community owns, runs and helps to oversee the school. The school aims to ensure that students grow into active citizens by encouraging them to contribute to the community and to develop their understanding of the faith and Hellenic culture.
The participants were drawn from the members of each faith-based school's management team. The selected participants included the principal, the deputy principal or assistant principal and the heads of respective sub-schools. In addition, other members of the management team such as the bursar, the director of mission, the dean of students and the dean of curriculum participated in the research.
After the non-participant observations were completed and the field notes transcribed, the data collection process progressed to conducting concept mapping and semi-structured interviews. In this study, semi-structured interviews and concept mapping were combined into one activity, as it was believed it would enable a more accurate picture of the participants' understandings (Newman, 2004; Pegg, 2007). The process began with each participant recounting a short history of their education and working background before exploring four inquiry areas. These four areas were as follows:
In the case of Demos College, the Greek Orthodox School, the findings revealed that the participants' understandings and practices of leadership were orientated towards teamwork. Thus the Greek Orthodox case was named: Perspectives Built on a Common Vision: Collective Leadership at Demos College. In the case of Caring College, the Catholic school, the participants' understandings of leadership were built on Gospel values. As a result, the Catholic case was entitled: Perspectives Grounded in Faith: The Servant Leaders at Caring College. In a similar manner, the Islamic school, Al-Huda College, also demonstrated how perspectives on leadership tend to be influenced by faith. This was a result of the way in which the participants grounded their understandings of leadership in values that had a distinct faith-dimension. Consequently, the Islamic case was called: Perspectives Guided by Values: Leading with Purpose at Al-Huda College.
The findings from the three cases illustrate how the participants' understandings of educational leadership were informed by a framework made up of personal values, which was then used to guide their educational leadership practice. In addition, the findings from the three cases reveal how the participants' perspectives were also influenced by other types of contextual factors that often had a faith dimension. Such observations have been captured in the following three over-arching themes which summarise the findings from the study reported here:
The significance of values in the participants' understandings of leadership has been captured by scholars such as Hodgkinson (1991), Starratt (1995) and Begley (2003) who have emphasised the importance of values in conceptions of educational leadership. Furthermore, the participants' belief in service connects with Greenleaf's (1991) secular conception of servant leadership, which involves the element of caring, demonstrating genuine compassion, and a personal level of concern and self-sacrifice (p. 243). Nevertheless, although the perspectives above align with Greenleaf's (1991) model and Hodgkinson's (1991) and Starratt's (1995) view on how morals and values are important aspects of educational leadership, for the majority of the participants in the study reported here, their values had a distinctly religious dimension. The way the participants' personal faith or spirituality was continually connected to their perspectives on leadership appears to substantiate Sullivan's (2006b) and Dantley's (2005, 2008) claim that faith has the ability to transform the meanings of these values beyond how they are generally understood within society. For example, the belief that leadership is about answering a 'call to serve' adheres to the idea that many Christians often adhere to the belief that this work should have a "purpose" (Sullivan, 2006a, pp. 76-77). In addition, the ways in which the participants from the Islamic school described how the Islamic teachings influence their understanding that leadership is to serve others aligns with Shah's (2006) contention that Islamic philosophy, particularly the Koran, is the "ultimate source" of values. Consequently, the participants' understandings of leadership in a faith-based school are, to some degree, distinct from the ways that educational leadership has been traditionally conceptualised.
I feel values; mainly Islamic values... are the things I need to practise. [Religious values] have to be there, to lead anyone, whether they come from an Islamic background or any other belief it doesn't matter, those values, the religious values have to be there, to lead anyone. [Leadership] comes from there.Additionally, the influence of faith on leadership practice is reiterated by the comments of another participant from the Greek Orthodox school:
For me faith and ethos are very, very strong. I have strong beliefs and I like to pass that on to my staff or work with my staff towards having that so that we all interact in a way that supports the ethos of the school... values underpin everything we do, definitely...Furthermore, the connection between values and practice was made explicit through the value of service. In this study, the participants connected their practice of leadership to the concept of 'serving others' which is strikingly similar to Strachan et al.'s (2009) investigation of leaders in Pacifica countries, where the discourse of service to justify and guide leadership practice was particularly evident. This finding is exemplified by one participant from the Catholic school who noted that "I always felt that my role as a teacher was to serve the students... now I am serving more the staff, but it is the same orientation". The idea that faith-related values influenced their practice was also made evident by how the participants from the Catholic school identified Jesus Christ as a guide or model for their leadership; describing him as "teacher", "a doer" and a "servant who was called to lead". As one participant suggested, "I look at the person of Jesus in the Gospels and I see someone who came to serve and he often said I have come not to be served but to serve".
This observation resonates with earlier work undertaken by scholars such as Begley (2003), Carlin and Neidhart (2008) and Dantley (2008) as well as that of Harris and Day (2003), which indicates quite clearly that leadership can be underpinned by values. However, the participants' viewpoints in this study reveal how values which are connected to the school's faith affiliation and/or their personal faith formed the very foundation for their leadership practice. Hence, these perspectives equate with Dantley's (2008) view that a leader's faith or spirituality, as well as the school's faith, can be a distinct and significant factor which guides a school leader's work. These influences on the leader's perspectives are further examined in the third theme which describes how such personal factors influenced the participants' leadership orientations.
More significant, however, is the extent to which the participants' perspectives were influenced by the contextual circumstances of their personal religious orientation and the school's affiliated faith. For example, one participant from the Catholic school commented:
... my own strong faith which I got from my mum and dad, growing up in a country with a strong Catholic influence, [and] the study I am doing influences my everyday thoughts and actions with staff and students and [the school's] community.This influence was also evident in perspectives of the participants from Al-Huda College. In this case the participants related their perspective of leadership to the notion of service. The participants' understanding of service was influenced by their personal faith, particularly the Islamic Prophet, Muhammad. As one participant's comment illustrates:
Serving others is from Prophet Muhammad. He is a guide to us. He was a servant to the people, he was a leader, a good leader, he was the best leader ... The way he was serving was as a servant to others. [That is] what is expected of a leader.Another of the participant's comments illustrates how her approach to leadership was supported by her faith: "I feel everything comes from God. That actually strengthens me ... that is the strength I have within myself in dealing with teachers".
As such, these participants could be characterised according to what Grace (2002, p.135) describes as "committed faith leaders"; in other words they are educational leaders who employ their personal spirituality to inform their perspective.
The way these various factors influence participants' perspectives reinforces Sullivan's (2006a) claim that leadership cannot be divorced from its context, as leadership is "intimately and inextricably interlinked with a particular way of life, one that is both personal and part of a living tradition" (p. 76). It is also important to draw attention to how these perspectives relate to the understanding that values are a motivating force on leadership and can arise from a variety of external and internal contexts, such as the self, the organisation and the transcendental as well as the individual's interactions with a group, organisation or society (Begley, 2003, p. 3). Furthermore, these perspectives show how understanding of educational leadership associated practices can be derived from either "an ethic of care, faith and morality" (Dantley, 2005, p. 18), or a "spiritual core" (Bolman & Deal, 2002, n. p.). In sum, these perspectives demonstrate how leadership is not derived from bureaucratic agencies but rather the combined ethos of personal faith and school's affiliated faith or a "sacred authority" (Sergiovanni, 1992, p.12)
The findings from the article reinforce understandings of the impact values can have on the ways in which leadership is understood and practised. Furthermore, these findings demonstrate how leadership can be connected to moral purpose. More significantly, the findings illuminate how the meanings of the values were transformed as a result of the participants' faith and the school's faith affiliation. Such connections have implications for those who prepare and develop future leaders and those who currently lead faith-based schools. As the article has portrayed, these perspectives relate to frameworks that leaders in state schools might use to guide their work, but they also demonstrate how the perspectives are distinctive to particular faith-based schools. Consequently, it would be desirable for current faith-based school leaders and those involved in leadership programs to include time for school leaders to identify their values and examine the extent to which those values influence their understandings and practice in order to address the particular needs of leading in a faith-based school (Lawson, 2005). This is a particularly important consideration given the complex nature of faith-based schools which serve both "God and Caesar" (Grace, 2009, p. 480).
The influence of faith on the participants' perspectives affirms the importance of context and the need for research to give due attention to various factors that influence a leader's work. The individual and collective perspectives of the participants take into account the way in which educational leadership can be informed and shaped by values and influenced by factors such as the school's faith affiliation, ethos and mission. In addition, the findings have highlighted how personal related factors, such as personal faith and education, make an impact on a leader's perspectives. As such these perspectives help to strengthen Greenleaf's (1991) and Sergiovanni's (1992) conception of leadership as being a spiritual and moral endeavour. Consequently, the findings have implications for contemporary conceptions of leadership that recognise the spiritual aspects of leadership as a way to move beyond more traditional notions of leadership (Dantley, 2008; Luckcock, 2007; Shah, 2006).
This article gives voice to a range of faith-based school leaders and offers an indication of how leadership is understood and practised in such settings. Attention needs to be placed on generating further case studies to depict the perspectives of faith-based school leaders in order to create a better understanding of leadership in faith-based schools and provide further evidence as to if and how faith-related values form the foundations of their perspectives. In this way the findings of this study may enhance the body of scholarly and empirical work on leadership and particularly the work of those who are engaged with investigating leadership from a wider range of perspectives.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2012). Schools, Australia, 2011 (Cat. No. 4221.0). Canberra, Australian Capital Territory: Commonwealth of Australia. http://abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/Lookup/4221.0main+features202011
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2009). Schools, Australia, 2008 (Cat. No. 4221.0 Re-issue). Canberra, Australian Capital Territory: Commonwealth of Australia. http://abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/DetailsPage/4221.02008
Begley, P. T. (2003). In pursuit of authentic school leadership practices. In P. T. Begley & O. Johansson (Eds.), The ethical dimensions of school leadership (pp. 1-12). Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Bolman, L. G. & Deal, T. E. (2002). Leading with soul and spirit. School Administrator, 59(2), 21-26. http://www.aasa.org/SchoolAdministratorArticle.aspx?id=10442
Bush, T. & Glover, D. (2003). School leadership: Concepts and evidence. Nottingham: National College of School Leadership. http://dera.ioe.ac.uk/5119/2/dok217-eng-School_Leadership_Concepts_and_Evidence.pdf
Campbell, C., Proctor, H. & Sherington, G. (2009). School choice: How parents negotiate the new school market in Australia. Crows Nest, New South Wales, Australia: Allen & Unwin.
Carlin, P. & Neidhart, H. (2008, October). From articulation to practice: Strengthening the cultural and spiritual dimension of leadership in schools of the 21st century. Paper presented at the Australian Conference of Educational Leaders, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. Retrieved from http://www.acel.org.au/
Cohen, L., Manion, L. & Morrison, K. (2000). Research methods in education (5th ed.). London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Crump, S. & Slee, R. (2005). Robbing public to pay private? Two cases of refinancing education infrastructure in Australia. Journal of Education Policy, 20(2), 243-258. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/0268093052000341430
Dantley, M. (2005). Faith-based leadership: Ancient rhythms or new management. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 18(1), 3-19. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09518390412331318423
Dantley, M. (2008). The 2007 Willower Family Lecture Reconstructing leadership: Embracing a spiritual dimension. Leadership and Policy in Schools, 7(4), 451-460. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/15700760802247411
d'Arbon, T., Duignan, P. & Duncan, D. (2002). Planning for future leadership of schools: An Australian study. Journal of Education Administration, 40(4/5), 468-485. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/09578230210440302
Dorman, J. P. & d'Arbon, T. (2003). Leadership succession in New South Wales Catholic schools: Identifying potential principals. Educational Studies, 29(2-3), 127-139. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03055690303281
Grace, G. (2002). Catholic schools: Mission, markets and morality. London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Grace, G. (2003). Educational studies and faith-based schooling: Moving from prejudice to evidence-based argument. British Journal of Educational Studies, 51(2), 149-167. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/1467-8527.t01-1-00231
Grace, G. (2009). Faith school leadership: A neglected sector of in-service education in the United Kingdom. Professional Development in Education, 35(3), 485-494. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13674580802532662
Greenleaf, R.K. (1991). Servant leadership: A journey into the nature of legitimate power and greatness. New York: Paulist Press.
Halstead, J.M., & McLaughlin, T. (2005). Are faith schools divisive? In R. Gardner, J. Cairns & D. Lawton (Eds.), Faith schools: Consensus or conflict? (pp. 61-73). London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Harris, A. & Day, C. (2003). From singular to plural? Challenging the orthodoxy of school leadership. In N. Bennett & L. Anderson (Eds.), Rethinking educational leadership: Challenging the conventions (pp. 89-99). London: SAGE.
Hodgkinson, C. (1991). Educational leadership: The moral art. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
Independent Schools Council of Australia (2012). Independent schooling in Australia Snapshot 2012. http://isca.edu.au/publications/independent-schooling-in-australia-snapshot/
Johnson, H. (2005). Reflecting on faith schools: An exercise in the sociological imagination. International Journal of Children's Spirituality, 10(2), 115-121. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13644360500154144
Lawson, I. (2005). Leading Islamic schools in the UK: A challenge for us all. Nottingham, England: National College for School Leadership
Lawton, D. & Cairns, J. (2005). Faith schools: Some political issues and an agenda for research. In R. Gardner, J. Carins & D. Lawton (Eds.), Faith schools: Consensus or conflict? (pp. 242-256). London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Luckcock, T. (2007). Faith in school leadership: Conceptualizing the distinctiveness and inclusiveness of church school headship. Management in Education, 21(2), 15-20. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0892020607076656
McGettrick, B. (2005). Perceptions in Christian schools. In R. Gardner, J. Cairns, & D. Lawton (Eds.), Faith schools: consensus or conflict? (pp.105-112). London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Newman, M. T. (2004). Practitioners' meanings of school leadership: Case studies of Jamaican high school principals. (Doctoral dissertation). Griffith University, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. http://research-hub.griffith.edu.au/display/n96a0ad080dee7e91ea3efb4be02ca17e
Patton, M. Q. (2002). Qualitative research and evaluation methods (3rd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Pegg, A. E. (2007). Learning for school leadership: Using concept mapping to explore learning from everyday experience. International Journal of Leadership in Education, 10(3), 265-282. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13603120701257412
Sacks, J. (2004, March). Leading schools of a religious character: Thoughts on being a faith school. Pre-event reading at the National College for School Leadership: Leading Edge Seminar Leading Schools of Religious Character.
Sergiovanni, T. J. (1992). Moral leadership: Getting to the heart of school improvement. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Shah, S. (2006). Educational leadership: An Islamic perspective. British Educational Research Journal, 32(3), 363-385. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/01411920600635403
Spry, G., Duignan, P. & Skelly, V. (2004, March). A framework for leadership in Qld Catholic schools: A report. Strathfield, New South Wales, Australia: Catholic Educational Leadership, a Flagship of Australian Catholic University. http://www.qcec.catholic.edu.au/upload/publicsite/qcec/research/framework_review.pdf
Starratt, R. J. (1995). Leadership with vision: The quest for school renewal. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.
Starratt, R. J. (1996). Transforming educational administration: Meaning, community, and excellence. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Strachan, J., Akao, S., Kilavanwa, B. & Warsal, D. (2010). You have to be a servant of all: Melanesian women's educational leadership experiences. School Leadership & Management, 30(1), 65-76. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13632430903509774
Strauss, A. & Corbin, J. (1990). Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE.
Striepe, M. (2011). Making the case for investigating leadership within the context of faith-based schools. Perspectives on Educational Leadership. Australian College for Educational Leaders.
Striepe, M. & Clarke, S. (2009). Faith-based schools in Australia: A fertile setting for research endeavour. Education, Knowledge and Economy, 3(2), 107-119. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17496890903166873
Sullivan, J. (2006a). Addressing difference as well as commonality in leadership preparation for faith schools. Journal of Educational and Christian Belief, 10, 75-88. http://www.jecb.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=117&Itemid=14
Sullivan, J. (2006b). Faith schools: A culture within a culture in a changing world. In M. de Souza, G. Durka, K. Engebretson, R. Jackson & A. McGrady (Eds), International handbook of the religious, moral and spiritual dimensions in education (pp. 937-947). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
Symes, C. & Gulson, K. N. (2005). Crucifying education: The rise and rise of new Christian schooling in Australia. Social Alternatives, 24(4), 19-24. http://discoverthought.com/Religion/References_files/SYMES%2005.pdf
Symes, C. & Gulson, K. N. (2008). Faith in education: The politics of state funding and the "new" Christian schooling in Australia. Educational Policy, 22(2), 231-249). http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0895904807307071
Whelan, B. T., Slattery, M. & Cannon, H. (2007, August). A framework for sustainable leadership in Broken Bay Catholic schools. Paper presented at the 4th Annual International Conference on Catholic Educational Leadership. Sydney, New South Wales, Australia. http://www.acu.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/89815/A_Framework_for_Sustainable_Leadership.pdf
Yin, R. L. (2009). Case study research: Design and methods (5th ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
|Authors: Michelle Striepe is Assistant Professor in the Graduate School of Education, The University of Western Australia. In addition to her particular interest in educational leadership, Michelle teaches in the areas of literacy and ICT in education.|
Simon Clarke is Professor and Deputy Dean in the Graduate school of Education, The University of Western Australia where he teaches, supervises and researches in the substantive area of educational leadership.
Tom O'Donoghue is Professor of Education in the Graduate School of Education, The University of Western Australia. He is also an elected Fellow of the Academy of the Social Sciences in Australia and of the Royal Historical Society. He specialises in the study of faith-based education and in educational leadership in challenging circumstances.
Please cite as: Striepe, M., Clarke, S. & O'Donoghue, T. (2014). Spirituality, values and the school's ethos: Factors shaping leadership in a faith-based school. Issues in Educational Research, 24(1), 85-97. http://www.iier.org.au/iier24/striepe.html